Historia Magazine

The magazine of the Historical Writers Association

  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
    • New Books
    • TV, Film and Theatre
    • One From The Vaults
  • Latest Releases
  • Columns
    • Doctor Darwin’s Writing Tips
    • Watching History
    • Desert Island Books
  • Awards
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Historia in your inbox

The Somme 1916 – From Both Sides of the Wire

28 July 2016 By James Burge

German Iron Cross SommeAbout two thirds of the way through the first episode of The Somme 1916 – From Both Sides of the Wire (BBC2; six parts starting 18 July; prod/dir: Alastair Laurence)  there is a sequence which could stand as a paradigm of what can be done with history on television. Peter Barton stands in the field where, a hundred years ago, inexperienced British soldiers, young pals recruited from northern towns, advanced towards German lines in the offensive that would later be known as the Battle of the Somme. The scene has been set with aerial drone shots, archive footage and plenty of music but now, crucially, there is no music.

Unlike many of his calling, the presenter shows no wild desperation to persuade us of the ‘incredible’ nature of his story. His arms do not gyrate like manic windmills nor is his delivery a staccato of plosives, forced out in a bid to inject passion into a flat script. Barton can do emotion, as we see in episode two, but here secure in his knowledge he recounts simple facts. The troops were told not to stop and shoot at the enemy. Apparently, all opposition had already been neutralised by British artillery fire. Likewise they were told not to run – a steady walk would be adequate. And there you have the story of the Somme: massive casualties which can be attributed to a combination of profound errors on the part of the British command and the inherent capacity for carnage of the new mechanised warfare. This is the story which most viewers already knew and, when we later hear an account from one of the (in fact plentiful) German defenders, recalling their surprise that the British were strolling towards them (“If they had run they could easily have overwhelmed us”), we realise that most viewers had it about right.

This six-part series will not shock viewers to the core by overturning their most dearly loved beliefs. Occasionally it flirts with that idea (yielding, presumably, to executive producer pressure) but in fact it offers us refinement rather than revelation. Our existing knowledge is enhanced through minor embellishments such as the apparently wilful desire on the part of the British to pass as much intelligence as possible to the enemy and even the dark hints that the balance of atrocities committed may lean more towards us than them.

The programme was, in a word, a commemoration and, as such, a fitting sequel to the live broadcast from the Somme memorial at Thiepval on the anniversary of the battle two weeks earlier. The ceremony, crafted deliberately for television, began with the sound of a whistle, just as it had a hundred years before. Serving soldiers spoke aloud the words written by combatants who were there on the first day and, not for the first time in history, ritual took a step towards drama. To be able to commemorate that ‘feeling of now’ from a moment in the past is something you can probably only achieve live and on the day. When it happens, though, it helps us to reinforce and re-examine one of those moments through which we collectively understand ourselves.

We might call such moments iconic in the very modern sense of being a brightly coloured picture which one can easily click in order to produce a desired response. There are many such icons on our national screen at the moment. Most of them would benefit from robust critical analysis. In the Battle of the Somme, however, we have one which, by virtue of its admissions of failure and its respect for participants on both sides, really does deserve its capacity to make the British feel good about themselves. That fact that, in these gentle yet powerful programmes, British factual television has managed to rise to the occasion is also a matter for pride, if not wonder.

The Somme 1916 – From Both Sides of the Wire is available on BBC iplayer

Photo: Jake Robinson

James Burge writes about history and makes promotional videos for writers.

Share this article:Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Email this to someone
email

Filed Under: TV, Film and Theatre, Watching History Tagged With: 1916, 20th century, Documentary, First World War, history, James Burge, Peter Barton, The Somme, TV review

Search

Latest Releases

The Lying Dutchman by Graham Brack

20 May 2022

Dead in the Water by Mark Ellis

19 May 2022

Widows of the Ice by Anne Fletcher

15 May 2022

See more new releases

Let’s stay in touch

Sign up for our monthly email newsletter:

Or follow us on social media:

Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Facebook

Editor’s Picks

From the Mill to Monte Carlo by Anne Fletcher

15 June 2021

William of Orange's army arrives in England

Why the Glorious Revolution was . . . well, neither

4 November 2018

Historia Q&A: Ben Kane

15 May 2018

Popular Topics

16th century 17th century 18th century 19th century 20th century 2020 Ancient Rome Andrew Taylor Anglo-Saxons author interview biography book review Catherine Hokin ebook Emma Darwin Giveaway historical crime historical fiction history HWA HWA Crown Awards HWA Debut Crown Award HWA Non-Fiction Crown interview Katherine Clements London Matthew Harffy medieval new release paperback research review Second World War Shortlist short stories the writing life Tudors TV drama TV review Vikings writer's life writing writing advice writing tips WWII

The Historical Writers’ Association

Historia Magazine is published by the Historical Writers’ Association. We are authors, publishers and agents of historical writing, both fiction and non-fiction. For information about membership and profiles of our member authors, please visit our website.

Read more about Historia or find out about advertising and promotional opportunities.

ISSN 2515-2254

Recent Additions

  • History, historicity, historiography and Arthurian legend
  • The Lying Dutchman by Graham Brack
  • Dead in the Water by Mark Ellis

Search Historia

Contact us

If you would like to contact the editor of Historia, please email editor@historiamag.com.

Copyright © 2014–2022 The Historical Writers Association