Historia Magazine

The magazine of the Historical Writers Association

  • Features
  • Interviews
  • Reviews
    • New Books
    • TV, Film and Theatre
    • One From The Vaults
  • Latest Releases
  • Columns
    • Doctor Darwin’s Writing Tips
    • Watching History
    • Desert Island Books
  • Awards
  • Events
  • Contact
  • Historia in your inbox

Escaping the Tudors

29 September 2016 By Linda Porter

henry-and-charlie

Linda Porter on why she’s happy to leave the sixteenth century behind.

Last year I appeared in two programmes in the Channel Five ‘Last Days’ series, talking about Mary Queen of Scots and Charles I.  Much of my contribution on Mary was eventually edited out because it did not fit the overall ‘well, she was a hopeless nitwit’ view of most of the other contributors.  Subtlety of historical analysis often plays second fiddle to talking heads desperate to promote themselves once placed in front of a camera.  I had actually felt less secure talking about Charles I as I had not finished my book about the experiences of his children during the Civil Wars but, strangely, the end result was, I thought, much stronger.  And it was just after I had finished filming my bit that I met the actor and writer Mark Gatiss, who was scheduled to be interviewed after me.

I had written three books on the Tudor period and he had played the irascible churchman Stephen Gardiner in Wolf Hall (as well as Oliver Cromwell on stage) but we agreed that the national obsession with the Tudors was mind-boggling.  He said he could not understand the continued fascination of ‘a fat king and his six wives.’  Neither can I.  So, having had enough of it, I was delighted to move on to the Civil Wars, a period I specialised in at university.  But I am still puzzled as to why this pivotal period of our history does not capture the popular imagination in the way that the fat king does.

The battles are, of course, remembered in the re-enactments of the Sealed Knot and Oliver Cromwell, the nemesis of the Stuarts, remains, in the words of John Morrill in the Oxford Dictionary of National Biography, ‘one of the most contended of Englishmen.’ Yet few people now, watching the colourful fights of ‘Cavaliers and Roundheads’, appreciate the nature of the crisis that tore the British Isles apart in the 1640s or know much about Charles I, other than that he was executed.

This extraordinarily rich period, which introduced many of the ideas by which we think we would like to live today, such as freedom of thought, religious toleration and inclusion of everyone in the political sphere, is in danger of becoming lost to several generations brought up on the Tudors and the First World War.  It has a direct link, through the republican tradition that was taken to the American colonies by Commonwealthsmen fleeing the retribution of the Restoration, with the American and French Revolutions and thence the modern world.  Although contemporaries, seeing the apparent overthrow of their ideals and the return of a privileged class of rulers, might have agreed with John Dryden’s cynical comment that ‘thy wars brought about nothing’ the longer view scarcely supports this. The English had put their king on trial for treason and found him guilty. In his last speech he reiterated the belief that had ultimately cost him his life: ‘a subject and a sovereign are clean different things.’  Nothing could ever be quite the same again.

The seventeenth century, with the notable exception of Charles II’s libidinous court, is often viewed as a dull time.  After all, wasn’t it Oliver Cromwell who abolished Christmas?  The answer is no; the suppression of the celebration of Christmas and the closure of theatres was ordered by the Presbyterian majority in Parliament in 1647, a group with whom the army and Cromwell were increasingly at odds.  It is true that both Charles I and Cromwell led exemplary personal lives and were very much family men, which means there is no procession of queens or mistresses to engage the interest of a wider audience.  Cromwellian London, however, was certainly not boring.  It was a hotbed of spies and informers, as fictionalised in SG MacLean’s fine historical crime novel, The Seeker, and it remained still the place to see and be seen.  The teenage Barbara Villiers, soon to become notorious as Lady Castlemaine, the greedy but fertile mistress of Charles II, started an affair with the earl of Chesterfield at the height of the Protectorate and exchanged erotic letters with him.  London was where they wanted to be.

Royal Renegades final coverI thoroughly enjoyed researching and writing my latest book, Royal Renegades: The Children of Charles I and the English Civil Wars and hope it may introduce a wider readership to this wonderful period.  I have no regrets about leaving the 16th century behind, except, perhaps, that I found 16th century historians, by and large, a congenial and collegiate bunch.  The Civil Wars have, for the most part, been the preserve of male historians who do not, rightly or wrongly, enjoy quite the same reputation.  I do not expect rave reviews from some of the specialists, though it would be nice to be proved wrong about this.  Meanwhile, it seems it may never be possible to escape the Tudors entirely.  I am due to give a paper on Mary Tudor and Mary of Guise at a conference to commemorate the 500th anniversary of Mary Tudor’s birth and I’ve been working as the historical consultant on the major new BBC1 series, Lucy Worsley’s Six Wives, which will be broadcast this autumn.  Something of a case of déjà vu.

Linda Porter’s book, Royal Renegades, is out on 6 October 2016.

Share this article:Share on Facebook
Facebook
Tweet about this on Twitter
Twitter
Email this to someone
email

Filed Under: Features Tagged With: 16th century, 17th century, Charles I, Charles II, English Civil Wars, Linda Porter, Oliver Cromwell, Stuarts, Tudors

Search

Latest Releases

Blood’s Campaign by Angus Donald

28 November 2019

Entertaining Mr Pepys by Deborah Swift

21 November 2019

House Histories: The Secrets Behind Your Front Door by Melanie Backe-Hansen

15 November 2019

See more new releases

Let’s stay in touch

Be the first to read our new features, articles and reviews; sign up now for updates by email:

Or follow us on social media:

Follow us on Twitter Follow us on Facebook

Editor’s Picks

In search of the animals in the Great Fire of London

21 November 2019

Rubicon by HWA authors

20 July 2019

William of Orange's army arrives in England

Why the Glorious Revolution was . . . well, neither

4 November 2018

Popular Topics

17th century 18th century 19th century 20th century Anglo Saxons author interview book review Books Catherine Hokin Competition Debut Crown Desert Island Books Dr Darwin Elizabeth Fremantle Emma Darwin exhibition Giveaway historical fiction Historical Writers Association history HWA HWA Crown Awards HWA Non-Fiction Crown Imogen Robertson interview James Burge Katherine Clements London Matthew Harffy new release Patricia Bracewell Q&A research Review Second World War Shortlist short stories the writing life Tudors TV drama TV Review Vikings writing writing advice writing tips

The Historical Writers Association

Historia Magazine is published by the Historical Writers Association. We are authors, publishers and agents of historical writing, both fiction and non-fiction. For information about membership and profiles of our member authors, please visit our website.

Read more about Historia or find out about advertising and promotional opportunities.

ISSN 2515-2254

Recent Additions

  • HWA Crown Awards 2020 are open for entries!
  • Unforgettable legacies of the East India Company
  • Reviews: Entertaining Mr Pepys by Deborah Swift

Search Historia

Contact us

If you would like to contact the editor of Historia, please email editor@historiamag.com.

Copyright © 2014–2019 The Historical Writers Association